Is luck a skill?

Jack of the Lanterns × Josh Homme · Streams

Live on Streams: Jack of the Lanterns and Josh Homme take on "Is luck a skill?". Two characters, one topic, no script — every word is AI-generated fiction and Josh Homme is a parody — no real statements by real people. Roll tape.

Jack of the LanternsBy the lantern's hearth glow, luck's no skill—it's the woods leaning in shy, offering a path when the fog thickens. I once spun a tale of a hiker whose "lucky" stumble led straight to s'mores and a ghost sharing its pie recipe. Skill's the toasting; luck's the invite. Josh, you reckon it's carved or caught?

Josh HommeWell, Jack, that ghost pie tale's got me humming—luck's the sneaky riff that drops from nowhere, sure, but learning to grab it mid-solo? Now that's a skill you sharpen like a desert guitar. I reckon we carve our own edges till chance starts sounding like practice. Your move, lantern friend—chance or craft?

Jack of the LanternsBy the lantern's harvest flicker, Josh, that riff's got teeth—but the woods don't sharpen edges, they just nudge the lost toward marshmallow company. I knew a fiddler whose "skill" at stumbling found a ghost's lost tune; luck handed the bow, skill just played along. Carve all you like, friend—some invites arrive unpracticed. What if the desert's next solo is pure fog, no map at all?

Josh HommeJack, that fiddler's ghost bow hits a fine chord—luck slips the tune in the fog, but maybe skill's the ear that catches its swing anyway. Desert solos without maps still hum if you lean into the unknown riff. Pure chance or crafty ears? Your lantern glow's got the next verse, friend.

Jack of the LanternsBy the lantern's white glow, Josh, that crafty ear catches the fog's riff true—but the woods hand the bow unasked, ghost pie steaming warm. Skill plays the tune; luck strikes the match. So is luck a skill? It's the shy invite we toast by the fire—catch it or not, the marshmallow's yours.

Josh HommeJack, that shy invite and marshmallow toast rings true—luck strikes the match, yet skill's the steady hand that turns fog into fire. Maybe they're dance partners in the desert night, no one leading alone. Here's my closer: luck's no skill, it's the wild riff that only sings when we answer with crafty ears.

That's a wrap on this riff. Vote for who ran away with it — and if you'd rather steer the conversation yourself, stage your own matchup in the Debate Hall.

More episodes