Greatest Quarterbacks of All Time — Yourlist

Greatest Quarterbacks of All Time

a Yourlist ranking · the crowd decides the order

From Super Bowl legends to record-shattering arms, which quarterback truly sits atop the NFL mountain? Cast your vote and help rank the all-time greats.

What counts: Rankings should weigh championships, individual accolades, statistical dominance, and overall impact on the game. All statistics are approximate as of recent seasons and subject to change with ongoing careers.

Tom Brady
Seven Super Bowl rings and two decades of relentless winning make him the consensus GOAT.
Super Bowl Titles: 7MVP Awards: 3Career Passing Yards: 89,214 yds
added by IJRin 3 rankings
0
Joe Montana
Mr. Cool in the clutch, Montana never threw a postseason interception in four Super Bowl wins.
Super Bowl Titles: 4MVP Awards: 2Career Passing Yards: 40,551 yds
added by IJRin 2 rankings
0
Peyton Manning
A record-setting mind for the game who redefined pre-snap mastery and offensive command.
Super Bowl Titles: 2MVP Awards: 5Career Passing Yards: 71,940 yds
added by IJRin 2 rankings Peyton Manning
0
Patrick Mahomes
Already a multi-time champion redefining what's possible with arm talent and improvisation.
Super Bowl Titles: 3MVP Awards: 2Career Passing Yards: 31,000 yds
added by IJRin 5 rankings Patrick Mahomes
0
Aaron Rodgers
Arguably the most naturally gifted thrower ever, with efficiency numbers that dazzle.
Super Bowl Titles: 1MVP Awards: 4Career Passing Yards: 62,975 yds
added by IJRin 2 rankings
0
Johnny Unitas
The original blueprint for the modern quarterback, revered for toughness and innovation.
Super Bowl Titles: 3MVP Awards: 3Career Passing Yards: 40,239 yds
added by IJR
0
Brett Favre
The iron man of quarterbacks, playing with gunslinger flair for two decades straight.
Super Bowl Titles: 1MVP Awards: 3Career Passing Yards: 71,838 yds
added by IJR
0
Drew Brees
Precision passing perfected, once holding nearly every meaningful career passing record.
Super Bowl Titles: 1MVP Awards: 1Career Passing Yards: 80,358 yds
added by IJRin 2 rankings
0
John Elway
A cannon arm and legendary comebacks, capped by back-to-back titles late in his career.
Super Bowl Titles: 2MVP Awards: 1Career Passing Yards: 51,475 yds
added by IJRin 2 rankings
0
Dan Marino
Redefined the passing game in the 1980s despite never winning it all.
Super Bowl Titles: 0MVP Awards: 1Career Passing Yards: 61,361 yds
added by IJRin 2 rankings
0
Steve Young
A dual-threat pioneer who succeeded Montana and won a title with historic efficiency.
Super Bowl Titles: 1MVP Awards: 2Career Passing Yards: 33,124 yds
added by IJR
0
Otto Graham
An early-era winning machine who reached championship games in nearly every season played.
Super Bowl Titles: 7MVP Awards: —Career Passing Yards: 23,584 yds
added by IJROtto Graham
0
Terry Bradshaw
Led the Steel Curtain dynasty to four titles in six years during the 1970s.
Super Bowl Titles: 4MVP Awards: 1Career Passing Yards: 27,989 yds
added by IJR
0
Roger Staubach
Captain America brought grit and clutch playmaking to America's Team.
Super Bowl Titles: 2MVP Awards: 0Career Passing Yards: 22,700 yds
added by IJRin 2 rankings
0
Ben Roethlisberger
A big-armed, bigger-bodied winner who captured two rings for Pittsburgh.
Super Bowl Titles: 2MVP Awards: 0Career Passing Yards: 64,088 yds
added by IJR
0
Russell Wilson
A Super Bowl champion known for mobility, deep-ball accuracy, and clutch late-game drives.
Super Bowl Titles: 1MVP Awards: 0Career Passing Yards: 42,000 yds
added by IJRRussell Wilson
0
Bart Starr
Vince Lombardi's field general, winning the first two Super Bowls ever played.
Super Bowl Titles: 5MVP Awards: 1Career Passing Yards: 24,718 yds
added by IJR
0
Fran Tarkenton
A scrambling innovator who put up huge numbers well ahead of his era's norms.
Super Bowl Titles: 0MVP Awards: 1Career Passing Yards: 47,003 yds
added by IJR
0
Warren Moon
A trailblazer whose combined pro and CFL numbers rank among the most prolific ever.
Super Bowl Titles: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passing Yards: 49,325 yds
added by IJR
0
Eli Manning
Two Super Bowl MVPs, both earned by upsetting historically great Patriots teams.
Super Bowl Titles: 2MVP Awards: 0Career Passing Yards: 57,023 yds
added by IJREli Manning
0
Josh Allen
A rocket-armed, bruising runner pushing the ceiling of quarterback athleticism.
Super Bowl Titles: 0MVP Awards: 0Career Passing Yards: 28,000 yds
added by IJRin 3 rankings
0