Greatest Fictional Detectives — Yourlist

Greatest Fictional Detectives

a Yourlist ranking · the crowd decides the order

From Baker Street to Netflix, which sleuth deserves the crown? Vote up the detectives whose wit, methods, and legacy define the genre for you.

What counts: Best = a mix of deductive brilliance, cultural staying power, and influence on the mystery genre; ratings are subjective and all figures/years are approximate.

Sherlock Holmes
The archetype every other detective on this list is compared to.
First Appeared: 1887Creator: Arthur Conan DoyleDeduction Skill: 10/10
added by IJR
0
Hercule Poirot
The fastidious Belgian whose 'little grey cells' cracked impossible cases.
First Appeared: 1920Creator: Agatha ChristieDeduction Skill: 9/10
added by IJR
0
Miss Marple
Proof that a sharp-eyed old woman in a small village misses nothing.
First Appeared: 1927Creator: Agatha ChristieDeduction Skill: 8/10
added by IJR
0
Batman
The World's Greatest Detective moonlighting as a caped vigilante.
First Appeared: 1939Creator: Bob Kane & Bill FingerDeduction Skill: 9/10
added by IJRin 2 rankings
0
Sam Spade
The hard-boiled template for every cynical noir gumshoe since.
First Appeared: 1930Creator: Dashiell HammettDeduction Skill: 7/10
added by IJRSam Spade
0
Philip Marlowe
Chandler's world-weary knight walking mean streets with a wisecrack ready.
First Appeared: 1939Creator: Raymond ChandlerDeduction Skill: 7/10
added by IJR
0
Nancy Drew
The teen sleuth who taught generations of readers to trust their curiosity.
First Appeared: 1930Creator: Carolyn KeeneDeduction Skill: 7/10
added by IJR
0
Dick Tracy
The square-jawed cop detective who pioneered gadget-driven crimefighting.
First Appeared: 1931Creator: Chester GouldDeduction Skill: 6/10
added by IJR
0
Columbo
The rumpled lieutenant who always had 'just one more thing' to ask.
First Appeared: 1968Creator: Richard Levinson & William LinkDeduction Skill: 8/10
added by IJRin 2 rankings Columbo
0
Encyclopedia Brown
The kid detective who solved neighborhood mysteries for a quarter a day.
First Appeared: 1963Creator: Donald J. SobolDeduction Skill: 6/10
added by IJREncyclopedia Brown
0
Jessica Fletcher
The mystery writer whose small town somehow had a body every week.
First Appeared: 1984Creator: Peter S. FischerDeduction Skill: 7/10
added by IJR
0
Adrian Monk
An OCD-driven genius who turns his phobias into forensic superpowers.
First Appeared: 2002Creator: Andy BreckmanDeduction Skill: 8/10
added by IJRAdrian Monk
0
Kinsey Millhone
The alphabet-series PI who brought hard-boiled grit to a female lead.
First Appeared: 1982Creator: Sue GraftonDeduction Skill: 7/10
added by IJRKinsey Millhone
0
Auguste Dupin
The original armchair genius who basically invented the detective story.
First Appeared: 1841Creator: Edgar Allan PoeDeduction Skill: 8/10
added by IJR
0
Inspector Morse
The opera-loving Oxford detective who solved crimes as much through instinct as logic.
First Appeared: 1975Creator: Colin DexterDeduction Skill: 7/10
added by IJR
0
Veronica Mars
A teen noir heroine who turned high school into her own private eye beat.
First Appeared: 2004Creator: Rob ThomasDeduction Skill: 7/10
added by IJR
0
Benoit Blanc
The modern Southern-drawled detective proving whodunits are alive and well.
First Appeared: 2019Creator: Rian JohnsonDeduction Skill: 8/10
added by IJR
0
L (Death Note)
The eccentric genius detective who turned a battle of wits into a global manhunt.
First Appeared: 2003Creator: Tsugumi OhbaDeduction Skill: 9/10
added by IJR
0